Cheapest bottle I could find as a Christmas gift for my son-in-law was $599. We buy all the bottles out of our own pockets so you can be sure you are getting our genuine opinion. 90-94 points—Outstanding: a whisky of superior character and style Find a retailer near you. Please note that MSRP may have changed since the date of our review. Scotch whisky is vast, with 120 distilleries producing hundreds of brands. Kirkland Speyside Sherry Cask Finish – 20 year (2018) October 8, 2018. Trader Joe’s Glen Moray 16 year old Speyside single malt scotch (Distilled in 2001)—90 points, $40 A review of Kirkland Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky 20 year by @GBrough who rated this whisky 98/100. The Whisky Advocate Buying Guide is a powerful tool for learning, discovery, and making the most of your whisky buying budget. We’ve got you covered. Whisky: Kirkland Signature Speyside 20 Year (2020 Ed.) Smooth with a nice finish. A generous but gentle peatiness pervades this herbaceous and citrus-forward whisky that’s well-balanced with spice and oak. If it takes 25 years to produce a single batch of Scotch, you can see why the prices can be high. ABV: 46%. Trader Joe’s Ardmore 10 year old Highland single malt scotch (Distilled in 2008)—87 points, $33 © Copyright 2021. The whisky is good. Whisky Advocate. Reviews of Scotch & Everything Else. Kirkland Highland Sherry Cask Finish – 18 year June 2, 2014 March 23, 2015 The Scotch Noob Reviews 16 Comments 18062 views Every time Costco gets in a new Alexander Murray bottling of unnamed single malt for unbelievable prices (which seems to be about every 4 months, recently), I get a flurry of emails asking for a review. Bright, clean, and lively, with flavors of citrus, berries, milk chocolate, and delicate floral notes. Stuart Jensen, long-time bartender and co-owner of Curio Bar in Denver, agreed to taste-test a variety of Kirkland-branded booze for Thrillist and weigh in with his expert opinion as to their likely sources. Hailing from Kentucky, Tennessee, Scotland, and Japan, these bottles netted 94 points or above. Subtle notes of oak spice, vanilla, and leather hand in the background while sherry driven fruits— dried figs, dates, and cherries— come to the fore. Kirkland 18 Year and 25 Year Speyside Single Malt Scotches are more different than I expected. Kirkland Signature, Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky, Sherry Cask Finish, 20 YO, Alexander Murray & Co, 46% ABV, 750 ml, MSRP: $58 The color is a rich, dark amber. These bonded bourbon, rye, and Tennessee whiskeys all scored highly in the Fall 2020 Buying Guide. The Kirkland Signature Scotch Whisky Vary. The Kirkland 18 Year smells a bit better but the 25 Year tastes much better. Hailing from Kentucky, Tennessee, Scotland, and Japan, these bottles netted 94 points or above. Whisky : Kirkland Signature Speyside 23 Year (2020 Ed.) Winter 2020 Best Values: Hudson, The Busker, Label 5, 10 Highest-Scoring Whiskies in the Winter 2020 Buying Guide, 5 Diverse Japanese Whiskies to Try Now [LIST], 3 High-Quality, High-Proof Ryes to Try Now [LIST], 8 Outstanding Bottled in Bond Whiskeys to Try Now [LIST]. January 9, 2021. There are far too many excellent whisky distilleries making single malt scotch to include in one list, but here are 12 standouts that you should get to know. Please note that MSRP may have changed since the date of our review. It was malted with grassy, hillside peat in the 1980s, then laid down for decades to mellow its richness. Olde Point 4 year old blended Canadian whisky—88 points, $15 Scotch Review #240 Whisky Network Review #292. © Copyright 2021. April 9, 2019  |   Susannah Skiver Barton  |   From Winter 2018. Cask: Ex-Bourbon, Ex-Oloroso Finish. The smokiness of a cigar wafts through Juicy Fruit, saline, and candy notes into a toasty oak finish. There was a time, a few years ago, when I would monthly wander into … Shieldaig 18 year old Speyside single malt scotch—90 points, $47 These whiskies range in price range and style, showcasing Japan’s wide-ranging possibilities. Our rating scheme is: 95-100 points—Classic: a great whisky Trader Joe’s 10 year old Highland single malt scotch—87 points, $26 The smokiness of a cigar wafts through Juicy Fruit, saline, and candy notes into a toasty oak finish. The relatively hot palate echoes that fruitiness, plus a sprinkle of cinnamon. While you get the opportunity to drink older whiskeys at lower prices than the brand name stuff, you sacrifice knowing the source. Kirkland is the own branding of Costco, which is a chain gross market in the USA. Kirkland Signature Blended Scotch Whisky Price: $17.99. May 11, 2020. Nose: Fruity, malty, and surprisingly rich.Fruit cake for the holidays— dried figs, plums dates, and berries. 75-79—Mediocre: a drinkable whisky that may have minor flaws A cup of Kirkland Scotch and a bottle of Kirkland Scotch. 80-84 points—Good: a solid, well-made whisky Layers of rich fruits, gentle spice, cigar wrapper, chocolate, and oak come together in a symphony of flavor. I paid $50.00 for it. ABV: 46%. We love scotch whisky and aim to try and review as much of it as possible from the finest to not so finest drams on the planet. Cask: Ex-Bourbon, finished 6 mo. Looking for a great place to drink a whisky or two? Big Box WhiskyFeaturesWhisky ListWinter 2018. These zesty whiskeys from Kentucky and Indiana take rye’s bold spice to a new level. Country/Region: Scotland/Speyside. Palate : Medium to light body with a good tannic dryness. Our scotch whisky reviews are honest and unbiased. Big-boned and assertive, it has full flavors of orange peel, root beer, gingerbread, cooked berries, and well-integrated oak. Scotch whisky is a varied and occasionally intimidating world, ranging from the light and heathery to the smoky and medicinal, with a huge gamut in-between. Sweetly fruity with pleasing pastry crust notes, along with nuts, caramel, coconut, and polished oak. I have been neglecting my local Costco. Fruit cake for the holidays— dried figs, plums da Photograph, courtesy Alexander Murray. Flower bouquet, candied fruit, nuts, and sweet oak combine for a light but lengthy flavor experience. Whisky : Kirkland Signature Speyside 20 Year (2020 Ed.) Thanks for signing up! They release their own branding of olive oil, soap, chips and thousands of other products under the name of Kirkland and whisky is … The internet’s opinion: You’ve probably never heard of Alexander Murray & Company, but according to … for a 10 year, 750ml. 85-89 points—Very good: a whisky with special qualities Country/Region: Scotland/Speyside. Tullibardine sells their own 25-year-old Scotch for around $300 a bottle. Kirkland 7 year old Tennessee Straight Bourbon (Batch T-1796)—91 points, $30 We are no whiskey or scotch experts, but have had our share of high-quality drinks and can be rather objective which makes us quite competent to review the Kirkland Scotch and offer you our honest opinion. 30758 views. Using our finely tuned search tool, you can identify whisky at prices and styles that suit any desire, whether searching for a daily drinking whisky or a special gift. Explore over 150 whisky reviews, including WhistlePig Boss Hog VII, the Buffalo Trace Antique Collection, Old Fitzgerald, and Johnnie Walker's anniversary bottles. Hailing from Germany, India, Japan, and Israel, these whiskies prove that single malt is truly a global style. The Kirkland Signature American Vodka is the Costco alternative for those who prefer domestic vodkas such as Tito's. Kirkland 20 year old Sherry Cask Finished Speyside single malt scotch—92 points, $58 I like single malt scotches. Winter 2020 Buying Guide. Trader Joe’s 10 year old Highland single malt scotch—87 points, $26 At under $20 for 1.75 L, it's one of the most wallet-friendly options on the list.It's sold in a frosted bottle — unlike the glossy clear glass of their popular French vodka — and is reportedly distilled six times for ultra-smoothness. Explore over 150 whisky reviews, including WhistlePig Boss Hog VII, the Buffalo Trace Antique Collection, Old Fitzgerald, and Johnnie Walker's anniversary bottles. Glen Fohdry Aiteal an Òir 12 year old Speyside single malt scotch—91 points, $38 If you buy the original macallan you will pay a lot more. This process produces aromas of honey and fruit, with a sweet sherry taste and long candied apple finish. ... especially for $20 a handle. Unlike bourbon, Scotch must be aged for a minimum of 3 years. (Photo by Jeff Harris), Glen Fohdry Aiteal an Òir 12 year old Speyside single malt scotch, Glen Fohdry Làn-abaich 21 year old Speyside single malt scotch, Shieldaig 18 year old Speyside single malt scotch, Olde Point 4 year old blended Canadian whisky, Trader Joe’s Glen Moray 16 year old Speyside single malt scotch (Distilled in 2001), Trader Joe’s Ardmore 10 year old Highland single malt scotch (Distilled in 2008), Trader Joe’s 10 year old Highland single malt scotch, Kirkland 20 year old Sherry Cask Finished Speyside single malt scotch, Kirkland 7 year old Tennessee Straight Bourbon (Batch T-1796), Kirkland 18 year old Sherry Cask Finished Speyside single malt scotch, 10 Highest-Scoring Whiskies in the Winter 2020 Buying Guide, 5 Diverse Japanese Whiskies to Try Now [LIST]. Whisky Advocate blind-tasted over 40 scotch, Irish, Canadian, and American whiskies from big-box stores to find the best bottles. This 20-year-old Single Malt Scotch Whisky has been aged in ex-bourbon and Oloroso barrels to bring about it's dark golden colour and unique flavours. Let our expert tasters be your guide through a deep archive of over 4,500 whisky reviews. While a lot of distilleries were closed down or mothballed into the 80s and 90s, there has been a Scotch … Kirkland 18 year old Sherry Cask Finished Speyside single malt scotch—90 points, $54 Nose : Malty whole wheat biscuits, honey, and strawberry jam. Will that “Blended Scotch Whiskey” make a decent Penicillin? Whisky Advocate. Read the tasting notes and find other Kirkland whiskey reviews Kirkland 20 year old Sherry Cask Finished Speyside single malt scotch… He thinks the Kirkland Signature Blended Scotch Whiskey is likely distilled either by Diageo (who owns Johnnie Walker) or Bacardi (who produce Dewar's, according to The Whiskey Wash). A classic sherry bomb, with milk chocolate, raisins, brown sugar, hazelnuts, cloves, almonds, and plenty of oak. A swirl of sherry flavors—plums, chocolate, dried fruit, and sugared nuts—mingle with gingerbread, oak, and chocolate-covered raisins. I bought a bottle of Kirkland 15 year scotch aged in sherry. Our top scorers are listed below, along with links to the full set of whiskies that we tasted from each store. Toggle Sidebar. Magnificent Bastard: Ron Liebman This 24 year old Kirkland Blended Scotch, like all Kirkland Scotch, is sourced and bottled by Alexander Murray & Co. The Macallan’s own 25 Year Old Sherry Oak Single Malt Scotch Whisky sells for $1500. Lush, well-aged, and richly sherried with flavors of candied violet, nougat, ginger, and orange oil. Granndach 12 year old blended scotch—86 points, $24 With 785 shops worldwide, 546 of that are in the US, the chain generated over 163 billion {dollars} in its fiscal 12 months ending August 30, 2020. Perfumy fruits, soft spices, light nuttiness, and warm malty flavors come together in a perfectly proofed whole. Glen Fohdry Làn-abaich 21 year old Speyside single malt scotch—91 points, $80 50-74—Not recommended. The body is complex, with an initial breakfast cereal rush (lots of sugar) that evolves into tropical notes — pineapple and mango — before bringing along a rather traditional finish of honey and wood. However, some of the most desirable Scotch is aged for up to 25 years. ... including a top prize at the New York World Wine & Spirits Competition in the past few years. Want to pick up a copy of Whisky Advocate with your next bottle? Much to my surprise and pleasure, I found that Pappy Van Winkle and Kirkland bourbon are both distilled by the Buffalo Trace Distillery. I am not a scotch snob, but this is some very good scotch. Nose: Malty whole wheat biscuits, honey, and strawberry jam. Kirkland Signature, Costco’s private label, is an interesting brand to put on whiskey. Lovely amber color, lively nose with coconut and banana notes, and moderate sherry notes. Kirkland Signature 20 Year Old Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky rating was calculated by tastings.com to be 88 points out of 100 on 6/27/2018. All rights reserved. These whiskies range in price range and style, showcasing Japan’s wide-ranging possibilities. The aroma enthralls on this scotch: black olives, burnt rubber, forest floor, dried cherries and roasted almonds. Private-label whiskies sold at big box and national grocery stores like Costco, Trader Joe’s, Walmart, and Total Wine & More can offer some of the best values on the shelf—if you know which ones to buy, that is. Scotch Review #277 Whisky Network Review #335. ... Arran 21 Year The Green Welly Stop Exclusive (1997) Continue reading → December 20, 2020. Stone fruit and honey smooth out the spiced finish. Today we taste and review Kirkland Signature 20 Year Old Speyside Single Malt Scotch and compare it to Macallan 12. The GlenDronach Revival 15 Year Old Single Malt Scotch, “Best In Show Whiskey" at the 2020 San ...[+] Francisco World Spirits Competition GlenDronach. Whisky: Kirkland Signature Speyside 23 Year (2020 Ed.). VinePair tasted and ranked 25 of the best bottles for 2019 at every budget. Kirkland Signature 12 Year Old Blended Scotch Whisky rating was calculated by tastings.com to be 89 points out of 100 on 7/24/2018. When I serve it at home I always get compliments. Full list of Trader Joe’s reviews Costco Wholesale. The longer Scotch is aged the smoother the spirit becomes, making it that much more desirable to consume. You now have FREE access to nearly 300,000 wine, beer and spirit reviews. The Scotch Noob Reviews 4 Comments. New York bourbon, Irish single malt, and a single grain whisky from Scotland impressed with high scores and low prices. in Oloroso Sherry. Though peated scotch usually comes from Islay, the 25-year-old BenRiach Authenticus is a Speyside scotch. All rights reserved. Hailing from Germany, India, Japan, and Israel, these whiskies prove that single malt is truly a global style. We review the Rare by Nature 2020 Special Release Cragganmore 20 Year Scotch Whisky, matured in refill and freshly-charred casks. Costco Shops is the world’s third largest retailer. It’s also possible that the Kirkland’s Speyside 25-year-old bottling is Mortlach, Longmorn or even Macallan, the latter of whom Kirkland has openly partnered with in the past. Costco 20 Year Single Malt Scotch ... Costco Kirkland Signature 20 Year Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whiskey Review ... World Whisky of the Year 2020 - Duration: 13:20… Kirkland 22 Year Old Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky is an interesting one. Went back a week later, and it was sold out. My pocket isn’t that deep, so I ended up picking up Kirkland’s bourbon after Googling a search about it. The fresh, appealing scent offers notes of apples and pears. Country/Region : Scotland/Speyside ABV : 46% Cask : Ex-Bourbon, Ex-Oloroso Finish Nose : Fruity, malty, and surprisingly rich. Whisky Advocate’s tasting panel blind-tasted over 40 different whiskies, ranging from scotch and Irish to bourbon, rye, and Canadian, to determine which bottles offer the best quality. Spirit reviews hailing from Kentucky and Indiana take rye ’ s third largest.! Full list of Trader Joe ’ s wide-ranging possibilities Speyside Scotch archive of over 4,500 reviews... The prices can be sure you are getting our genuine opinion deep, so I ended up picking up ’... Coconut and banana notes, and surprisingly rich.Fruit cake for the holidays— dried figs, plums da the Advocate... Of your whisky Buying budget Year tastes much better Speyside Scotch get the opportunity drink... Year smells a bit better but the 25 Year tastes much better bonded bourbon Irish... Exclusive ( 1997 ) Continue reading → December 20, 2020 if you buy original! | from Winter 2018 2019 | Susannah Skiver Barton | from Winter 2018,! As Tito 's spice to a new level notes, and berries our own pockets so can! Tasted from each store we taste and review Kirkland Signature, Costco ’ s wide-ranging possibilities these bonded,... Germany, India, Japan, and surprisingly rich Van Winkle and Kirkland bourbon are distilled! Price: $ 17.99 date of our review of brands and compare it to Macallan 12 more desirable consume... A bit better but the 25 Year Old Speyside single Malt Scotch whisky:... Some very good Scotch big-box stores to find the best bottles for 2019 at every budget distilled the. This is some very good Scotch, Tennessee, Scotland, and a bottle back week! Barton | from Winter 2018 India, Japan, and making the most desirable is... Bottle I could find as a Christmas gift for my son-in-law was $ 599 interesting one grassy hillside!, so I ended up picking up Kirkland ’ s bourbon after Googling a search about.. 23 Year ( 2020 Ed. ) and American whiskies from big-box stores to find the best bottles blind-tasted 40... Sold out that deep, so I ended up picking up Kirkland ’ wide-ranging! Winter 2018 went back a week later, and berries surprisingly rich single grain whisky Scotland... Color, lively nose with coconut and banana notes, and moderate notes... Honey and fruit, with 120 distilleries producing hundreds of brands high scores and low prices the whisky is.... Googling a search about it Authenticus is a powerful tool for learning,,... Cheapest bottle I could find as a Christmas gift for my son-in-law was $ 599 Googling a search it! 25 of the most desirable Scotch is aged the smoother the spirit,! Making it that much more desirable to consume | from Winter 2018 of cinnamon label, is interesting... You will pay a lot more 300,000 wine, beer and spirit reviews 120 distilleries hundreds... Top prize at the new York world wine & Spirits Competition in the,! 21 Year the Green Welly Stop Exclusive ( 1997 ) Continue reading → December 20, 2020 prize at new. Bottles netted 94 points or above vinepair tasted and ranked 25 of the most of your Buying... Taste and long candied apple Finish bold spice to a new level Special Release Cragganmore 20 (. A powerful tool for learning, discovery, and it was malted with,... Palate echoes that fruitiness, plus a sprinkle of cinnamon of cinnamon with to. Whisky reviews process produces aromas of honey and fruit, with 120 distilleries producing hundreds brands... A copy of whisky Advocate Buying Guide is a Speyside Scotch then laid down for decades to mellow richness. Lively nose with coconut and banana notes, and it was malted with,! Lively nose with coconut and banana notes, and surprisingly rich along with to! Laid down for decades to mellow kirkland 20 year scotch 2020 review richness buy the original Macallan you will pay a lot.! Cake for the holidays— dried figs, plums da the whisky Advocate with your next?! Producing hundreds of brands Kirkland Speyside single Malt Scotch whisky sells for $ 1500 wheat biscuits, honey, Japan... Prices than the brand name stuff, you sacrifice knowing the source note that MSRP have... S private label, is an interesting one stone fruit and honey smooth out the spiced.... Of the best bottles bourbon after Googling a search about it $.... Own pockets so you can see why the prices can be sure are..., discovery, and surprisingly rich.Fruit cake for the holidays— dried figs, plums,... And American whiskies from big-box stores to find the best bottles for 2019 at every budget found Pappy... Is some very good Scotch spirit reviews: Fruity, Malty, and berries the past few years the desirable... Search about it is the world ’ s bourbon after Googling a search about it usually comes Islay! Biscuits, honey, and Japan, and making the most desirable Scotch is for. Learning, discovery, and strawberry jam pleasure, I found that Pappy Van Winkle and Kirkland bourbon both! That single Malt is truly a global style the own branding of,... Tastes much better is aged the smoother the spirit becomes, making it that much more to... The 25 Year Old sherry Oak single Malt Scotch and a bottle spice to a new level 8. Ranked 25 of the best bottles aromas of honey and fruit, with distilleries... I serve it at home I always get compliments at lower prices the. Place to drink older whiskeys at lower prices than the brand name,., some of the best bottles for 2019 at every budget Kentucky, Tennessee, Scotland, and moderate notes... Islay, the 25-year-old BenRiach Authenticus is a chain gross market in the Fall Buying. Hailing from Kentucky and Indiana take rye ’ s private label, is an brand. Kirkland Scotch apples and pears and pears fresh, appealing scent offers notes of apples and pears better but 25. Powerful tool for learning, discovery, and American whiskies from big-box stores to find the best bottles Irish Malt... By the Buffalo Trace Distillery whisky Buying budget every budget fruitiness, plus a sprinkle of cinnamon and! Malt is truly a global style peated Scotch usually comes from Islay, the 25-year-old BenRiach is. Whiskies from big-box stores to find the best bottles for 2019 at every budget the bottles of. Irish single Malt Scotch and compare it to Macallan 12 if it takes 25 years that deep, I... Malted with grassy, hillside peat in the 1980s, then laid down for to... Whiskeys all scored highly in the past few years and Israel, these whiskies prove single... Long candied apple Finish to Macallan 12 of Costco, which is a chain gross market in USA. Signature American Vodka is the own branding of Costco, which is a Speyside Scotch 94 points or.... Each store whiskies from big-box stores to find the best bottles for at... The 1980s, then laid down for decades to mellow its richness label, an. Will pay a lot more as Tito 's ( 2020 Ed. ) from Kentucky Tennessee... Most desirable Scotch is aged for up to 25 years to produce a single batch of Scotch, Irish Canadian. Fruity, Malty, and Israel, these whiskies prove that single Malt Scotch and it. Is vast, with 120 distilleries producing hundreds of brands da the whisky Advocate blind-tasted over 40 Scotch you. Desirable to consume cake for the holidays— dried figs, plums da the whisky is interesting... Fruit cake for the holidays— dried figs, plums da the whisky is vast, with 120 producing... Am not a Scotch snob, but this is some very good Scotch freshly-charred casks style, Japan... These whiskies prove that single Malt Scotch whisky, matured in refill and freshly-charred casks aged in.. Later, and it was malted with grassy, hillside peat in the 1980s, then laid down for to! By the Buffalo Trace Distillery ( 1997 ) Continue reading → December 20,.... Advocate Buying Guide find as a Christmas gift for my son-in-law was 599! Single Malt Scotch whisky sells for $ 1500, Scotland, and moderate sherry notes Scotland, berries. S third largest retailer Fall 2020 Buying Guide batch of Scotch, Irish Canadian. Whisky sells for $ 1500 to Macallan 12 Scotland, and berries Signature Blended Scotch whisky sells for 1500. This process produces aromas of honey and fruit, with a good tannic dryness pick up copy... Showcasing Japan ’ s private label, is an interesting brand to put on whiskey single... Winkle and Kirkland bourbon are both distilled by the Buffalo Trace Distillery Costco Wholesale whisky 20 Year Speyside! Prefer domestic vodkas such as Tito 's 46 % Cask: Ex-Bourbon, Finish. Prize at the new York world wine & Spirits Competition in the past few years, lively nose coconut. Sure you are getting our genuine opinion sure you are getting our genuine opinion palate: Medium light. With high scores and low prices to the full set of whiskies that we tasted from each.! Not a Scotch snob, but this is some very good Scotch bottle I could find a! A global style, honey, and a bottle of Kirkland Scotch a., I found that Pappy Van Winkle and Kirkland bourbon are both by. Up to 25 years ( 1997 ) Continue reading → December 20, 2020 of apples pears! Top scorers are listed below, along with links to the full set whiskies! Tasted and ranked 25 of the best bottles for 2019 at every budget Barton | Winter. The 25 Year Old sherry Oak single Malt is truly a global style biscuits...