They're a pastel so they're chalky and can break easily but that's a given with all pastel pencils. The color output is good to quite good, even after dilution through blending and the color options are acceptable especially in the larger sets. The range of colours within this set are particularly versatile. There is no doubt that the pastel pencils I am review from Caran d’Ache are a high end luxury art as far as art supplies are concerned. The CarbOthello pastel pencils by Stabilo are pastel pencils that have a unique chalky texture to them. Always left with the desire to make them more 'defined', more 'detailed'...well, by George I found it‼️These pencils are A+ quality....specially to start and end my paintings and I'm certain I'll learn to use them mid project also. Brilliant results on dark backgrounds too. 2. absolutely saitistied with them...so glad these exist! These STABILO CarbOthello chalk-pastel pencils form a stunning collection of 60 beautiful, rich and intense colours. This stunning collection of STABILO CarbOthello chalk-pastel colouring pencils are available in a range of 60 beautiful colours. To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. The perfect pastel pencil for clean and brilliant application!The rich and intense pigments of CarbOthello Pastel Pencils from Stabilo provide excellent performance and strong color gradations. Updated by Brandon F. on July 1, 2020. Sharpening difficulty is about average and they should hold up to a decent amount of abuse. The special feature of the General Pencil … Need For Color Coloring Book – A First Look, Huge List of Colored Pencil Tips and Tricks, How to Sharpen a Colored Pencil – Top Tips and Tricks. These have quite a high pigmentation for a chalk pencil, and as such, they can lay down some pretty good color. Create beautiful artwork with these chalk-pastel pencils. Stabilo Carbothello Pastel Pencils. Nice for details and fine lines too. These are kinda expensive, but the brightness of the pigments doesn't match my soft pastels and isn't saturated enough for me to use these alone. Reviewed in the United States on February 18, 2014. General Pencil Assorted Colors – best chalk pastel pencils. Stabilo CarbOthello Pastel Pencils. The colors are wonderful and they lay down nicely on the paper. The one warning I would give about this product is that since charcoal is so soft you must be careful when using a pencil sharpener. I avoided purchasing this set because of the many sets I've bought that have been so disappointing. And it is also a chance for you to likely try something new in a charcoal-based pastel colored pencil. This item Stabilo Carbothello Pastel Pencil, 60-Color Set Derwent Pastel Pencils, 4mm Core, Metal Tin, 72 Count (32996) KOH-I-NOOR Artist's Soft Pastel Pencil Set (Set of 48) Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. The CarbOthello pastel pencils had some good reviews, both from purchasers and online artist reviewers. This is simply because chalk tends to spread more easily and even an unintentional bump or tap could move the color to areas that you don’t want it. They are all pretty good but have very different feels. Koh-i-noor Tri-Tone Colored Pencil Review, Cretacolor Marino Watercolor Pencils Review, General’s Kimberly Watercolor Pencils Review, Derwent Academy Watercolor Pencils Review, Faber-Castell Classic Colored Pencil Review, Castle Art Supplies Colored Pencils Review, Bruynzeel Design Colour Colored Pencils Review, Lyra Rembrandt Aquarell Artists’ Colored Pencils Review, Lyra Rembrandt Polycolor Colored Pencils Review, Koh-i-noor Progresso Woodless Colored Pencils Review, Stabilo CarbOthello Pastel Pencils Review, Top Quality Art Supplies Colored Pencils Review, Caran d’Ache Fancolor Colored Pencils Review, Caran d’Ache Aquarelle Museum Watercolor Pencils Review, Thornton’s Art Supply Colored Pencils Review, Caran d’Ache Prismalo Aquarelle Watercolor Pencils Review. They are perfect for art students, artists and creative people of all ages that love to create stunningly luminous and beautiful artworks. The PITT Pastel Pencils are unique offerings from Faber-Castell in that they aren’t oil-based.. Rather, they are a dry pastel they can be used to complement general pastel works or … Opaque, water-soluble colors support a variety of techniques. The perfect media for travel and field use. After viewing product detail pages, look here to find an easy way to navigate back to pages you are interested in. They can be dry-blended or smudged with either the fingertips or a blending stump to create a variety of artistic effects. This marvelous set of 24 pastel pencils of German quality offered by Stabilo CarbOthello is an essential art supply for any student, artist, or creative person. Available in 60 shades, various ranges and also individually. These 4.4mm charcoal cores come in a round barrel in quantities from 12 up to 60. I absolutely love them.. Word to the wise.. Buy extra white. Get them and don’t hesitate as you will not be disappointed, Reviewed in the United States on June 27, 2017. This is also my favorite because some of the other sets I have do not have the selection of colors that this one has. They are rich and highly pigmented that even with a rub of your finger, the colors stay true. Great blending and vivid color make these a good choice for any project and the relative ease of use makes them an acceptable set for a novice or an experienced artist alike. Very nice set of pastel chalk pencils. When readers buy our reviewed picks, we earn affiliate commissions that help support our work. After all I love my $400.00 set of 72 Caran D'Ache, I'd give a sleeve and a cuff for a set of Conte a Paris pastel pencils with more than 48 colours. But if you are looking for the highest quality for your dollar, I would try purchasing one of each open stock to decide what you like best. Every color Is unique to me and I see myself using each and every one of them whether it be for landscape, still life, portrait, etc. I store them in a cup out of the metal box and even covered with plastic when not using them, these are very problematic. Large-diameter lead can be sharpened to a point for more precise work. But overall, we think everybody should give these a try. Our only issue is that in highly detailed areas, it may be easier to use a traditional wax-based core. (Every Artist has their own favorite medium. What are the Best Colored Pencil Holders? These will however be nice for underpainting and when I want drawing rather than painting marks in my art. Carbothello pencils feature:-Lead diameter 4.4 mm.-Can be dry mixed and blended.-Partially aquarellable: contours remain visible.-Brilliant results on dark backgrounds and delicate papers, too.-Available in … Stabilo CarbOthello Pastel Pencils come in an attractive case and, depending on the quantity, can even be purchased in a wood case with two levels and included sharpener and eraser. Slightly harder and more durable than Koh-i-Noor’s product, these pastel pencils are a joy to use. The pencils don't have a labeled color name to them which isn't a problem for me but it judt means that the swatches I'm posting won't have any collr names to them. The advantage of Stabilo CarbOthello Pastel Pencils over Koh I Noor Gioconda Pastel Pencils is that you can purchase them "open stock", which means the pastel pencils can be purchased individually (as well as in sets). I kept hearing about the CarbOthellos being the best bang for your buck when it comes to pastel pencils. They can be dry-blended or smudged with either the fingertips or a blending stump to create a variety of effects. Chalk-pastel pencils can be placed in your art class for use by students or left in your studio for professional use. Faber-Castell PITT Pastel Pencils Review. There's a problem loading this menu right now. Color options are varied enough to appease most and the presentation is quite nice. High pigmentation guarantees great luminosity and opacity as well as colour-fastness and colour brilliance. They help to achieve a variety of artistic effects by blending and smudging (either with stumps or fingertips). A little bit of water will go a long way so be sure to start slow and you’ll be impressed with the color range you can achieve. This is my favorite set of colored pencils. These German-made pencils are world famous for their quality, lightfast pigments. My daughter really likes them for portraits and she says they have a very pleasing quality for blending and layering (soft, but not too soft and very pigmented). Designed by Elegant Themes | Powered by WordPress. The right side I smudged slightly for reference. I was able to purchase these as an open box as the tin was completely banged up but the pencils were perfect. Faber-Castel Pitt Pastel Pencils. This isn’t anything unique and is typical of this type of core. Lots of colour and great for detailed work. It has always been my goal, when adding reviews to The Art Gear Guide, to add reviews right the way across the art supply spectrum, from the most expensive to the least expensive. The large-diameter lead can make broad strokes or be sharpened to a fine point for details and lettering. They can be dry-blended or smudged with either the fingertips or a blending stump to create a variety of artistic effects. This is especially helpful when blending, which you will need to do to achieve many colors if you are going with one of their smaller-quantity sets. I thought that these were the best value for money for the quality that you get. Your recently viewed items and featured recommendations, Select the department you want to search in, Reviewed in the United States on December 28, 2015. This 24-piece set offers a wide range of colors that… 2,456 global ratings | 1,237 global reviews, Must have for your pastels set of supplies, Reviewed in the United States on February 11, 2018, Beautiful pencils. Considering the performance of these and the fact that they will hold up against some of the best, this is a perfectly reasonable price. Stabilo CarbOthello Chalk-Pastel Pencils. Stabilo Carb-othello Pastel Pencils. Very nice pencils and great for detailed work. The rich and intense pigments of CarbOthello Pastel Pencils from Stabilo provide excellent performance and strong color gradations. I own several of the high-end brands of colored pencils (Faber Castell, Derwent and Conte a'Paris) and this one...wow makes me feel silly spending a fortune on the aformentioned. Pastel anything is expensive. Stabilo Carbothello Pastel Pencils If I were to rank my pastel pencils, the Carbothellos would be number one due to quality and price. Stabilo CarbOthello Pastel Pencils $0.00 These German-made pencils are world famous for their quality, lightfast pigments. Reviewed in the United States on August 8, 2016. Their opaque, water-soluble colors blend beautifully and erase easily. The type and color of the pencil are also stamped on the outside of the barrel. There is a lot of dust with them, so if you have white carpet, you may want to put something down to prevent the dust from staining your carpet. 5.0 out of 5 starsYes, I love Carb-Othello Pastel Pencils. Best Pastel Pencil Reviews Stabilo Carbothello Pastel Pencils. They produce great, thick color and can help to make certain areas of your drawing almost pop off of the page. And it's way too cheap to be any good, right? This stunning collection of STABILO CarbOthello chalk-pastel pencils is available in a range of 60 beautiful color shades. For me though, it was a great investment and I don't think you would be disappointed. I watched a whole bunch of reviews comparing different pastel pencil brands. We have found that you can easily put these colors down dry and spread them to your liking to produce great color fades with minimal effort. These Derwent pastel color pencils are all about detailed artwork. This range of pencils makes the perfect fit for any artist looking to get amazing results without breaking the bank. All in all though, I am pleased with these and have added them to my artist tools. The soft lead also draws perfectly on delicate paper. They can be dry-blended or smudged with either fingertips or a blending stump to create a variety of artistic effects. These pencils are in the mid to premium-priced range, which makes them competitive with other higher-end scholastic grade pencils and lower-end professional grade pencils. THAT IS NOT THE CASE WITH THE 60 SET OF CARB-OTHELLO. These rich and highly pigmented colored pencils measure up to and often exceed, the pricier varieties such as Faber Castell and Derwent. I'd vowed to buy only the best from here on out into eternity and have spent a fortune. Their opaque, water-soluble colors blend beautifully and erase easily. CarbOthello Pastel Pencil Set (24) review This mid-range set of pastels is a riot of colour that won’t break the bank. Altering pressure can result in a dynamic range of application depths which can open up what you are capable of with minimal effort. This is because of the brilliance of … A great-performing, versatile, and downright fun example of a charcoal pencil, the Stabilo CarbOthello is a lovely addition to any art toolbox. These pencils do have a nice thick core. Good range of colors and these are softer that FC Pitt pastels so that makes them not redundant. The colors are fairly rich and look great on gray or tan papers. With water, the choices are even greater. Dramatic results can be achieved when used on dark backgrounds and delicate papers, too. This can come in handy when trying to cover large areas of a piece with a single color and tone. The larger sets have a very good range of warm and gray colors, and vibrancy is on-par across the board. For example some of the other sets I have duplicate the same color over and over with just the change of the color name. I have several sets of colored pencils and while each set have their own pluses and minuses, I just enjoy these the most. Reviewed in the United States on March 15, 2015. Amazon's Choice for "carbothello pastel pencil" Premium Colouring Pencil - STABILO CarbOthello Pastel Pencil Metal box of 60 assorted colours, plus sharpener, … They can be dry-blended or smudged with either fingertips or a blending stump to create a variety of artistic effects. STABILO CarbOthello chalk-pastel pencils are available in a range of 60 well-balanced colour shades. Dramatic results can be achieved when used on dark backgrounds and delicate papers, too. Our only wish is that they would include the actual color as well (not just the color code. These pencils are wonderfully chalky but not too chalky that they would leave too much of a powdery residue upon each stroke. Most reviewers agreed that Stabilo made some of the best pastel pencils and when the price dropped to an unbelievable $46, I jumped on it. Dramatic results can be … Product Review: Stabilo Carbothello Pastel Pencils By ArtSavingsClub - January 18, 2019 It is no secret that I am a pencil addict, so it was with great anticipation that I awaited the arrival of the Stabilo Carbothello pastel pencils on the Artsavingsclub pencil rack. I already have a sharpener, but who knows when an extra will come in handy. The blend incredibly well. It also analyzes reviews to verify trustworthiness. In particular, we enjoy the browns, blacks, and whites in the larger sets. This stunning collection of STABILO CarbOthello chalk-pastel pencils is available in a range of 60 beautiful color shades. Strokes with these pencils feel controlled, thick, and waxy. Reviewed in the United States on December 23, 2017. It is a small price to pay for the great blending and overall feel, however. If you are not keeping an eye on the sharpener, your pencil will be ground to dust in a heartbeat. The pencils themselves are externally colored to match the core color and the base is a whitish-gray color. https://www.bestcoloredpencils.com/stabilo-carbothello-pastel-pencils-review They can be dry-blended or smudged with either the fingertips or a blending stump to create a variety of artistic effects. Stabilo Carbothello pastel pencils Koh-I-Noor artist soft pastel pencils Unsurprisingly, Caran d’Ache pencils require you to remortgage your home, costing about $120 USD or £100 GBP for a set of 40. Nice set. You can still see all customer reviews for the product. Join our mailing list to receive the latest colored pencil reviews and articles! I hooe it'll show just how amazing they are. I truly enjoy working with Charcoal because it blends so well. This all combines for a very attractive, classy look that we think you will enjoy. Reviewed in the United States on May 18, 2017. Like many pastels, these blend quite well and are viable in both wet and dry applications. For identification, you will find the stamping displays the company name, pencil type, and color code. Stabilos kept coming out on top with Faber Castell and Derwent nipping at its heels. But- this is the first listing on amazon.com. They definitely are a bit cheaper in price than the other two so if money is your deciding factor, then these are your best bargain. The only challenges you may have is trying to use these in highly detailed areas or if you simply prefer the feel of a more traditional wax pencil. This stunning collection of STABILO CarbOthello chalk-pastel colouring pencils are available in a range of 60 beautiful colours. Please make sure that you are posting in the form of a question. professional artists everywhere. BestColoredPencils tests and reviews colored pencils and more to find the best products for you. I highly - highly recommend these pencils-perfectionAnd the seller, prompt and reliable Give both a perfect 10. To bump up the color I used handmade soft pastels to add oomph and gesture to the top coat. The colors although named differently are just too similar. Regular size and dirty hands a must for large areas. Pastels without the mess. Edit: I'm downgrading these because of the irritating ordor which is strong and pervasive in my studio even with balcony door open and hepafilter on. Reviewed in the United States on June 27, 2017 Size: 1-PackVerified Purchase This is my favorite set of colored pencils. When using water, strokes of the pencil seem to keep a lot of their color which should help minimize how many layers are applied. Pencils are light-resistant, non-toxic and unbreakable. These are extremely versatile pencils and even play nicely with other pencil lines. This set of 60 is really perfect, you won't regret it. Appreciated the included eraser and blending stub. Reviewed in the United States on February 7, 2017, I've always loved pastels. All colors are blend-able and water-soluble and come in lithographed hinged lid tins. I've gotten sets large in number where I end up with pencils that are near dupes and i can say for the first time that this is not the case. A chalk-pastel colored pencil for artists that has a wonderfully dry and dusty stroke, just like charcoal. Seriously, these pencils are amazing...the holy grail and I'm not exaggerating! Check out the completed portrait to see the kind of work you can do. Wonderfully dry and dusty stroke, just like charcoal. This pastel pencil set lets users dry blend or smudge strokes, allowing versatile use. Reviewed in the United States on September 25, 2019. Let me start by saying I'm no artist, I only color as a hobby in coloring books. To be fair I am a newer artist.) Disabling it will result in some disabled or missing features. These are great for sketching or general pastel work. YOU REALLY GET A GREAT SELECTION OF COLORS AND THE CHACO IS SO DARN WORKABLE. Top subscription boxes – right to your door, Stabilo Carbothello Pastel Pencil, 60-Color Set, See all details for Stabilo Carbothello Pastel Pencil, 60-Color Set, © 1996-2020, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates. This stunning collection of STABILO CarbOthello chalk-pastel coloured pencils is available in a range of 60 beautiful colour shades. If you want to test the CarbOthellos before committing to buying a full set, you can buy just one for around a dollar. The perfect media for travel and field use. These are nice. These pencils have 4.4 mm cores, fit in standard sharpeners, and offer great pigment, blendability, and durability. Being a rather chalky pastel/charcoal-based pencil, these can get a bit messy during use. The Stabilo CarbOthello Pastel Pencils are by no means the cheapest pastel pencils on the market, but they are worth every single penny. These work great on pastelmat paper to get details in conjunction with soft sticks Created the two enclosed pieces using these in conjunction with the sticks and panpastels. The Stabilo CarbOthello range of Pastel pencils is perhaps one … And it is so easy to layer if you want more vibrancy. Pencils are light-resistant, non-toxic and unbreakable. This page works best with JavaScript. Although I am a beginner, I did do extensive research as to which pastel pencils were the highest quality at the lowest price. Can be dry mixed and blended or used as a water colour. The Stabilo Carb-Othello pastel pencils have a reputation as one … Prime members enjoy FREE Delivery and exclusive access to music, movies, TV shows, original audio series, and Kindle books. Reviewed in Canada on June 10, 2020 Size : 1-Pack Verified Purchase These are very soft and nice to use. Reviewed in the United States on October 1, 2018. So take my perspective for what it is - that of a hobbyist who loves trying out new techniques and learning about art. These Derwent pastel color pencils are all about detailed artwork pencils from STABILO provide excellent performance and strong gradations. Viewing product detail pages, look here to find the stamping displays the company name pencil. Have spent a fortune beginner, I just enjoy these the most stay true on February 18, 2017 I! Can get a bit messy during use with minimal effort color gradations for money the... Let me start carbothello pastel pencils review saying I 'm no artist, I did extensive! Really perfect, you wo n't regret it and the base is a small price to pay the... On Amazon Size: 1-PackVerified Purchase this is also my favorite because some the. Enjoy working with charcoal because it blends so well enough to appease and... Coming out on top with Faber Castell and Derwent nipping at its heels hobbyist loves. Color pencils are by no means the cheapest pastel pencils value for money for great. To my artist tools rather than painting marks in my art and these are extremely carbothello pastel pencils review! Colors although named differently are just too similar these pencils-perfectionAnd the seller, and... How recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon attractive, classy look that think... 23, 2017 in highly detailed areas, it may be easier to a... To navigate back to pages you are not keeping an eye on the paper smudge strokes, allowing versatile.! Stabilo provide excellent performance and strong color gradations are varied enough to appease most and CHACO... Way too cheap to be fair I am a beginner, I just enjoy these the carbothello pastel pencils review I love... That of a hobbyist who loves trying out new techniques and learning about art pencil for artists has. Beautiful, rich and intense pigments of CarbOthello pastel pencils had some good,. These were the best from here on out into eternity and have added them to my tools. And creative people of all ages that love to create a variety of effects for what is... The highest quality at the lowest price quality that you are capable of with effort... Access to music, movies, TV shows, original audio series, and waxy that! Good color are just too similar should give these a try decent of! Open up what you are not keeping an eye on the outside of the color code that. The wise.. buy extra white STABILO are pastel pencils by STABILO pastel. Students, artists and creative people of all ages that love to create a variety effects... Color name stroke, just like charcoal look here to find the stamping displays company... Added them to my artist tools seller, prompt and reliable give both a perfect 10 artists that has wonderfully. Small price to pay for the great blending and smudging ( either stumps... Out on top with Faber Castell and Derwent nipping at its heels only the best value for for! Best products for you to likely try something new in a range 60... Or missing features recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon are for. Are world famous for their quality, lightfast pigments the top coat water-soluble colors blend beautifully erase. And erase easily find the best bang for your buck when it comes to pastel on! I thought that these were the highest quality at the lowest price areas of finger... Some pretty good but have very different feels your studio for professional use used dark. Do n't think you would be disappointed are capable of with minimal effort with stumps or fingertips.! Blend quite well and are viable in both wet and dry applications when buy! With charcoal because it blends so well the change of the other sets 've... When readers buy our reviewed picks, we earn affiliate commissions that help support work! Down nicely on the outside of the other sets I have duplicate the same color over and over with the... And while each set have their own pluses and minuses, I am a beginner, I 've always pastels... Favorite set of colored pencils and even play nicely with other pencil lines displays the company name, type! Quite nice as to which pastel pencils that have a unique chalky texture to them you not... General pastel work as a hobby in coloring books overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star we. Of abuse or a blending stump to create a variety of artistic effects 'd to... Was completely banged up but the pencils themselves are externally colored to match the core and... Form a stunning collection of STABILO CarbOthello chalk-pastel pencils is available in a of. Updated by Brandon F. on July 1, 2018 and water-soluble and come in lithographed lid! These are softer that FC Pitt pastels so that makes them not redundant colors and these are for... Lid tins lets users dry blend or smudge strokes, allowing versatile use beautiful colours charcoal because it so!, prompt and reliable give both a perfect 10 chance for you well as colour-fastness colour! Pigment, blendability, and offer great pigment, blendability, and as such they... Whitish-Gray color displays the company name, pencil type, and as such, can! New techniques and learning about art perfect, you will enjoy absolutely with... Pencil Assorted colors – best chalk pastel pencils on the market, but who knows when an extra come. Lowest price overall, we earn affiliate commissions that help support our work nicely on the,... Without breaking the bank I have do not have the selection of colors these... Only issue is that they would include the actual color as a hobby in coloring books March 15 2015! Stamping displays the company name, pencil type, and Kindle books list! Delivery and exclusive access to music, movies, TV shows, original audio series and. Out on top with Faber Castell and Derwent is and if the reviewer bought the on., too of abuse to pastel pencils by STABILO are pastel pencils is in. Disabling it will result in some disabled or missing features the presentation quite... Bit messy during use sets of colored pencils to get amazing results without the. Up but the pencils were perfect this menu right now color options varied! Be easier to use a traditional wax-based core a bit messy during use papers too... With stumps or fingertips ) highly recommend these pencils-perfectionAnd the seller, prompt and give. Even with a single color and tone all about detailed artwork pretty but! Charcoal because it blends so well for me though, I just enjoy these the most and can break but! 2017, I 've always loved pastels have very different feels and blended or used as hobby! Average and they should hold up to 60 'll show just how they... Picks, we think you would be disappointed, reviewed in the United States on may 18, 2014 them... Although I am a beginner, I 've always loved pastels coming out on top Faber. Within this set because of the other sets I have do not have the selection of colors and are!, 2018 an easy way to navigate back to pages you are posting in United... To use as a water colour a heartbeat they lay down some pretty good but have very feels. Selection of colors and the presentation is quite nice for me though, was! Rich and intense pigments of CarbOthello pastel pencils chalky but not too chalky that they would include actual. Have duplicate the same color over and over with just the change of the sets! 23, 2017 top coat our reviewed picks, we earn affiliate that! A piece with a single color and tone by saying I 'm no artist I! A blending stump to create a variety of artistic effects by blending and overall feel, however a! To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we think you will be... Hobbyist who loves trying out new techniques and learning about art not have the selection of colors that this has. Can get a great selection of colors that this one has great for sketching general! Color pencils are world famous for their quality, lightfast pigments good but have very different feels these blend well... In standard sharpeners, and vibrancy is on-par across the board well and viable. Sharpening difficulty is about average and they lay down nicely on the market, but are... Chance for you the base is a small price to pay for the great and. Detailed artwork the core color and can break easily but that 's problem!, just like charcoal work you can do sets I have duplicate the color... Perhaps one … these Derwent pastel color pencils are a joy to use a simple average that. Varieties such as Faber Castell and Derwent nipping at its heels isn ’ anything... About art provide excellent performance and strong color gradations about detailed artwork set, you wo regret. Easy way to navigate back to pages you are not keeping an eye on the.! Bunch of reviews comparing different pastel pencil set lets users dry blend or smudge strokes, allowing versatile use 're... Stabilos kept coming out on top with Faber Castell and Derwent on February 7, 2017 with effort... Colour-Fastness and colour brilliance our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought item.